4:00pm chocolate chip cookies

It's hard to resist a recommendation from Serious Eats, especially when they go to such great lengths for something as important as the Chocolate Chip Cookie Championship. And while we mostly agree with their assessment, the baked in-house, Roasting Plant chocolate chip cookie, made with batter from Tom Cat bakery, is, in fact, pretty good - it's still a bit too chocolaty chip for us. But not too chocolaty chip to have again.
Roasting Plant Coffee, 75 Greenwich Ave, NY, NY 10014 (near West 11th)