4:00pm peanut butter cookie

I walked out of the subway in Brooklyn over the weekend and lo and behold a Milk Bar before my very eyes. I bought 2 crack pie slices, 2 candy bar pie slices, 2 peanut butter cookies and 2 cups of coffee. I debated, because I was taking the pies to a dinner party of 6, between buying only 2 slices versus the 4 but it seemed kind of cheap of me, though I knew we would only manage to finish 2.
Milk Bar Carroll Gardens, 382 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 (at 2nd Place)