Spoon

There is something intrinsically unappealing about pre-made sandwiches, no matter how good the ingredients are. Maybe it reminds me too much of airport food. But if you are going to have pre-made sandwiches, Spoon (or Tbsp, I'm not sure), is the place to go. The bread could be less obviously refrigerated, but the ingredients, the proportions and tastes are stellar.
Spoon, 17 W. 20th St, NY, NY 10010 (btwn 5th and 6th Ave)